Introduction
The Kingkiller Chronicle by Patrick Rothfuss has enthralled fans for years with its intricate storytelling and rich world-building. However, the long wait for the third and final book, “Doors of Stone,” has given rise to a plethora of intriguing theories and speculations within the fan community. In this article, we will explore some of the most compelling theories, ranging from the plausible to the downright conspiracy-driven. But before we delve into these theories, be warned: spoilers abound.
Theories and Speculations
1. Bast is Felurian’s Son
One theory that has intrigued fans is the idea that Bast, the Fae companion of Kvothe, might be the son of Felurian. This theory gains traction from Bast’s title, “Prince of Twilight,” which echoes Felurian’s own title, “Lady of Twilight.” Initially, some speculated that Bast could be Kvothe’s son due to the nickname “Reshi,” suggesting “father.” However, a Faen card deck endorsed by Rothfuss identifies Bast’s father as “Remmen,” a separate entity from Kvothe. While not disproving the theory entirely, this revelation does cast some doubt on it.
2. Count Threpe’s Hidden Agenda
A theory proposed by a Reddit user suggests that Count Threpe may have nefarious intentions towards Kvothe. Threpe’s involvement in finding a ship for Kvothe raises suspicion, especially as the ship later encounters a shipwreck. Ambrose, Kvothe’s rival, might have a hand in this, as Threpe is in a position to execute such a scheme. While this theory seems plausible, it’s important to consider Kote, the storyteller’s, motivations and reliability in narrating this part of the tale.
Also Read The Art and Cover Design of “The Doors of Stone”
3. Kvothe’s Lineage: The Lackless Connection
A widely accepted theory among fans is that Kvothe’s mother, Laurian, is actually Natalia Lackless, making Meluan Lackless his aunt. Clues supporting this theory include Kvothe’s sense of familiarity when meeting Meluan and Laurian’s association with Edema Ruh. A compelling piece of evidence comes from a linguistic analysis where Arliden’s song about his wife contains the line, “It’s worth my life to make my wife Not tally a lot less,” which, when read differently, sounds like “Netalia Lackless.” A German translation reinforces this connection, making it a strong theory.
4. Bredon is Cinder and Denna’s Patron
This theory suggests that Bredon, known for his mysterious absences, might be the elusive Master Ash, who is, in turn, Denna’s Patron. The connection arises from Bredon’s frequent absences coinciding with Denna’s. The Cthaeh mentions Denna’s patron as one who plays games, much like Bredon’s beautiful games of Tak. Furthermore, the Cthaeh alludes to Master Ash using a walking stick to beat Denna, matching Bredon’s possession of a walking stick. This theory hints at a deeper and more sinister connection between these characters.
5. Kvothe’s Father: Iax, not Arliden
This theory ties in with Kvothe’s mother Natalia Lackless. If Kvothe is the son of Iax, a legendary shaper, it would explain his extraordinary abilities. A quote from “The Name of the Wind” raises suspicion, with Arliden jokingly asking Laurian if she bedded down with a wandering god. Clues in the songs about Lady Lackless, suggesting she holds a secret behind a certain door, correlate with the notion that Iax is imprisoned behind the Doors of Stone, also known as Lackless doors. While intriguing, this theory remains speculative, lacking conclusive evidence.
6. Auri is Princess Ariel
Auri’s enigmatic character has sparked the theory that she might be Princess Ariel, about whom Kvothe claims to know the truth. The similarities in their names are the first hint. Auri’s behaviour is described in a manner reminiscent of a princess, and her collection of “treasures” in the Underthing aligns with the notion of her being the princess stolen from barrow kings. This theory, though reliant on various hypotheticals, draws interesting parallels between Auri and the mysterious Princess Ariel.
7. Kote is Denna
The most intriguing and radical theory posits that Kote, the innkeeper narrating the story, is, in fact, Denna. According to this theory, Kvothe is dead, and Kote represents the persona of Denna, who changes her name once again. It explains Kote’s self-loathing, which is not characteristic of Kvothe but is present in Denna. The theory suggests that Denna’s transformation into Kote is due to a betrayal by Kvothe. While this theory is a compelling narrative twist, its validity remains uncertain.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: When can we expect the release of “Doors of Stone”?
A1: As of my last knowledge update in September 2021, there was no official release date for “Doors of Stone.” Fans have been eagerly awaiting its publication, but it’s advisable to check for updates from the author or the publisher for the most current information.
Q2: Are these theories confirmed by Patrick Rothfuss?
A2: No, these theories are not confirmed by the author, Patrick Rothfuss. They are the product of fan speculations and discussions within the Kingkiller Chronicle community. Rothfuss has been notoriously tight-lipped about the plot of the third book, leaving fans to develop theories based on the information provided in the first two books.
Q3: Why do fans develop these theories?
A3: Fans develop theories to explore and engage with the rich and complex world created by Patrick Rothfuss. The long wait for the third book has fueled speculation and discussion, allowing readers to connect the dots and create their interpretations of the story’s mysteries.
A4: Patrick Rothfuss has occasionally commented on fan theories but has not confirmed or denied their validity. He has expressed appreciation for the enthusiasm of his readers and their creativity in interpreting his work. However, fans should not consider his comments as official canon.
